Questions to Ask a Divorce Attorney Before You Hire One

Nov 20, 2026

You get one hour, sometimes less. The attorney across the desk will spend most of it asking about you: how long you were married, whether there are children, what you own. Then comes the pause where you get to ask something back, and most people freeze.

The questions to ask a divorce attorney are not complicated. They cover how the attorney resolves cases, what it will cost, who will actually handle your file, and how fast your calls get returned. The answers tell you whether this office fits your situation, whatever your spouse is ready to do: mediate or fight.

What to Know Before You Call

Handwritten list of questions to ask a divorce attorney on a notepad beside a cup of coffee

Before you ask a divorce attorney anything, decide what you need from them. In Arizona, that comes down to one question: does your spouse want to fight? If the two of you broadly agree, you may need an attorney-guided mediation such as Divorced in a Day. If your spouse won’t cooperate, you need an advocate who handles contested divorce.

You don’t need to be certain. Many people arrive unsure, and a good consultation helps you sort it out. Still, a rough answer shapes which questions carry the most weight.

Two more things make the hour go further:

  • A short list of what you own and owe. Estimates are fine; the house, the retirement accounts, the cars, the credit cards.
  • The one or two outcomes you care about most. Keeping the house. A workable parenting schedule. Finishing by spring.

Write your questions down and bring the list. Nobody remembers the fourth question once the conversation starts.

9 Questions to Ask a Divorce Attorney at Your First Consultation

Calm law office waiting area with a couch and two separate conference rooms, the kind of setting to ask a divorce attorney about mediation

These nine questions to ask a divorce attorney cover the four things that decide your experience: the attorney’s approach, the cost, the people on your case, and the communication. Ask them in order. Short, direct answers are a good sign; vague ones tell you something too.

About How They Resolve Cases

  1. How do you usually resolve cases like mine? You want to hear a specific answer: how often their cases settle, how often they go to trial, and what they recommend for someone in your position. An attorney who leads with “it depends” and stops there hasn’t told you anything.
  2. Is mediation an option for us, and would you handle it? Some firms litigate only. Some refer mediation out. Ask whether the attorney mediates, what that looks like, and whether both spouses can work with the same office. In a mediation such as Divorced in a Day, two attorney-mediators guide both spouses without representing either one, which is a different role from the advocate you’d hire for a contested case.
  3. What happens if we start out agreeing and then stop? Agreements fall apart. Ask what the attorney does when that happens, and what the path looks like if you need to move from mediation to a contested case. The answer should come without drama.

About Money

  1. How do your fees work, and what is included? Ask whether the fee is hourly, flat, or a retainer you replenish, and ask what counts as a cost on top of the fee (filing fees, service, copies). The State Bar of Arizona’s How to Talk to Your Lawyer brochure is a plain-English reference on these terms, and it notes that Arizona lawyers may not charge contingency fees in a divorce.
  2. Will I get the fee agreement in writing before I pay? The answer should be yes. The same State Bar brochure lists a copy of your written fee agreement among your rights as a client, and says your lawyer must explain in writing the costs you may incur. If the office hesitates, keep looking.
  3. What usually makes a case cost more than expected? Every attorney has seen this. Common answers: a spouse who won’t produce financial records, repeated motions over temporary orders, or disputes about a business valuation. The answer tells you how the attorney thinks about your money.

About Working Together

  1. Who will handle my case day to day? At many firms the attorney you meet is not the one who drafts your documents or answers your emails. That isn’t a problem by itself. You just want to know the names, and you want to meet the paralegal who will know your file best. At our office that is Barbara Mendoza, who has handled family law files for more than twenty years and answers the phone from 9 to 5.
  2. How quickly do you return calls and emails? Ask for a number: same day, 24 hours, 48 hours. Then ask what happens when the attorney is in trial. Unreturned calls are a common complaint about lawyers, and they are the easiest thing to ask about up front.
  3. What would you want to know about my situation that I haven’t told you? This question flips the consultation. A thoughtful attorney will ask about the things that change your case: a prior marriage, a pending move, a spouse who controls the accounts, a safety concern. You learn how they think, and you leave with better questions than you came in with.

How to Read the Answers

Attorney passing a written fee agreement across a conference table to a client

A good consultation leaves you with specifics: a likely path, a written fee structure, the names of the people on your case, and a response-time promise. Compare the answers you got against the table below. One weak answer isn’t disqualifying. A pattern of them is.

QuestionA reassuring answer sounds likeA reason to keep looking
How do you resolve cases?“Most of our cases settle. Here’s what I’d recommend for you, and why.”“Every case is different,” with no example.
Is mediation an option?A clear yes or no, and who would handle it.Mediation is dismissed, or the attorney can’t describe how it works.
FeesA written agreement, the fee type named, costs listed separately.“We’ll figure it out as we go.”
Who handles my case?Names, roles, and an offer to introduce you.“Our team,” with no names.
Returning calls“Within one business day, and my paralegal covers trial weeks.”No number, or a sigh.

Notice what isn’t on the list: years in practice alone, office size, or how the attorney describes their own toughness. Those details rarely predict how your case goes.

How to Choose a Divorce Attorney When Your Spouse Won’t Cooperate

Woman taking a returned phone call from a divorce attorney at her kitchen counter

If your spouse wants to fight, choosing a divorce attorney changes in one way: courtroom experience moves to the top of the list, and so does how the attorney handles the first months of a case. The nine questions above still apply. You add a few about the contested path.

  • How many family law cases have you taken to trial, and how recently? Settlement is still the most likely outcome, but you want an attorney who the other side knows will try the case if needed.
  • How do you handle temporary orders? Who pays the mortgage and where the children sleep during the case often gets decided in the first months. Ask how the attorney approaches that stage.
  • What do you need from me to keep costs down? Organized financial records and prompt replies save hours. An attorney who tells you that plainly is looking out for your budget.

At Simonds Law Group, Kate Simonds leads contested work. She has handled hundreds of contested bench trials over more than fifteen years of family law practice. We prefer smooth and efficient resolutions whenever possible, and we are fully prepared when advocacy is necessary. Both paths are real paths here, and the consultation is where we help you decide which one fits.

What to Check Before You Walk In

Man at a home desk checking a divorce attorney's license and reviews on a laptop before a consultation

Three checks take ten minutes, and they tell you whether an office is worth your consultation hour at all. Do them the night before. None of them require a phone call, and together they rule out the offices that would waste your time.

  • Confirm the license. The State Bar of Arizona’s attorney search shows whether a lawyer is active and in good standing, along with any public discipline history.
  • Read the reviews for patterns. Stars alone tell you little. Look for repeated mentions of returned calls, clear bills, and how the office treated people under stress. Five reviews that say the same thing tell you more than one angry one.
  • Know the timeline nobody can change. Arizona requires a 60-day wait after service before a court can finalize any divorce (A.R.S. § 25-329), and one spouse must have lived in the state for 90 days before filing (A.R.S. § 25-312). We cover the full timeline in How Long Does a Divorce Take in Arizona? An attorney who promises something faster is promising what the law doesn’t allow.

Bring These Questions to Us

Simonds Law Group logo

Bring these questions to ask a divorce attorney to our Peoria office. For couples who broadly agree, Divorced in a Day answers most of them before you sit down: one day of attorney-guided mediation, two attorney-mediators, separate rooms, no court appearances, and a flat fee of $5,000 total for both spouses that covers filing, service, notary, and delivery fees. Flat fee, no surprises.

100% Agreement Rate — Every Divorced in a Day mediation session we’ve conducted has resulted in a full agreement.

There is no consultation fee to discuss Divorced in a Day with an attorney-mediator. If your situation calls for the contested path instead, we’ll tell you that in the same conversation. Call (480) 433-9747 or contact us at our Peoria office.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most important questions to ask a divorce lawyer?

The most important questions to ask a divorce lawyer are these four: how they usually resolve cases, whether mediation is an option, how fees work and whether the agreement is in writing, and who handles your case day to day. Add how quickly they return calls. Those answers tell you more about your experience than years in practice alone or office size.

Should I meet with more than one divorce attorney?

Many people do, and it helps if the first consultation left you unsure. Bring the same list of questions to each office so you can compare answers directly. If the first attorney gave you a clear path, a written fee structure, and named the people on your case, a second meeting may not be needed.

Can my spouse and I use the same divorce attorney?

One attorney cannot represent both of you in a divorce. In an attorney-guided mediation such as Divorced in a Day, two attorney-mediators work with the two of you in separate rooms as neutrals, without representing either spouse. If your spouse wants to fight, each of you needs your own attorney.

What should I bring to a first meeting with a divorce attorney?

Bring a rough list of what you own and owe, your questions written down, and any papers already filed if your spouse has started the case. You don’t need every statement yet. The goal of the first meeting is to find the right path and the right office. The details come later.

This article is intended for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.